Wine Spectator: Smeriglio Merlot 2010......91points
Wine Spectator 2013: Smeriglio Syrah 2010 93 Points
August 2012 James Suckling: 94 point to Pinot Nero 2010 Baracchi "One of the best Pinot Noirs in Italy"
"Very pure, exhibiting black cherry, blackberry, spice and tar notes. Picks up a tobacco accent, making this Tuscan, yet shows a different fruit and textural profile overall. Fine length."